pH, conductivity and nutrients: aiming for the right balance
In aquaponics, pH is the result of a permanent compromise. Tomatoes would prefer slightly acidic water, at around 6.0, but the bacteria in the filter and the fish need a more neutral environment. In practice, the 6.4 to 7.5 range used in aquaponics suits everyone; for tomatoes, staying in its lower half, between 6.4 and 7.0, helps the uptake of iron and phosphorus. Dropping to 6.0 as in pure hydroponics is neither possible nor desirable here, as it would stress the livestock.
Conductivity provides a second useful benchmark. In aquaponics, it remains much lower than in hydroponics: in the comparative trial by Yang and Kim, the water in aquaponic systems planted with tomatoes was around 0.6 mS/cm at the third month, whereas the hydroponic solution was kept at 2.0 mS/cm. Low conductivity is therefore not, on its own, a sign of deficiency. As soon as the first flowers appear, the situation reverses: the need for nitrogen decreases while the demand for potassium and phosphorus rises sharply, as these two elements govern fruit set, size and flavour.
This is the whole difficulty of growing tomatoes in aquaponics. Fish water is rich in nitrogen but often poor in potassium, calcium and iron. It is corrected with measured additions, for example potassium sulphate, or by alternating pH correctors so that calcium is also covered. Regular monitoring with reliable water tests remains essential, and the guide on iron deficiency will help you make the right diagnosis when faced with yellowed young leaves with green veins.