Water test, strips or drops

Written by Tristan Ulrich · October 18, 2026
Mallette de tests d’eau ouverte avec flacons de réactifs et tubes, près d’un aquarium planté

A water test takes only a few minutes and prevents most accidents in aquariums, ponds and aquaponics alike. This guide compares test strips, liquid reagent kits and electronic probes, with their real accuracy and their cost per measurement.

Choosing your water test: strips, drops or probe

The water in an aquarium, a pond or an aquaponic system stays clear long after its parameters have gone off course. That is the whole difficulty: the eye detects neither ammonia, nor nitrites, nor a drop in pH, yet these three parameters can kill a stock within days. A water test is the only way to see a problem coming before it becomes costly.

Three families of equipment share the market: reactive test strips, colorimetric drop tests and electronic instruments. None is universally better, and each suits a specific use. This guide compares their real-world accuracy, their cost per test and their ease of use, then goes through the sampling method, how to read the colours and the mistakes that throw everything off.

Test tube of aquarium water changing colour after the reagent is added

Why carry out a water test

Testing is not a perfectionist's quirk, it is a diagnosis. Clear water can contain enough ammonia to burn the fishes' gills, and slightly green water can show perfect parameters. Clarity only tells you about suspended particles, nothing more.

The need is greatest during the first few weeks, when the nitrifying bacteria are becoming established. The nitrogen cycle takes place in three stages, with an ammonia peak followed by a nitrite peak before things stabilise. Without measurements, it is impossible to know where you stand and when to introduce the first fish safely. Afterwards, testing becomes a tool for monitoring and diagnosis. When a fish stays at the bottom, when the plants turn yellow or when the water turns cloudy, the parameters point you straight to the right cause instead of leading you to try treatment after treatment at random.

Multi-parameter water test strip with its coloured pads after immersion 7-in-1 water test strips, aquarium and pond

Test strips, one minute on the clock

The test strip is a plastic strip carrying several reactive pads. You dip it in the water for a second, shake off the excess, wait for the stated time and compare the colours with the chart supplied. Five to seven parameters are read in a single movement.

Its strengths are speed and low entry cost. Its weakness is resolution. The charts work in wide steps, often 0, then 10, then 25, then 50 mg/L for nitrates, which is enough to spot a trend but not to steer finely. Opinion is unanimous: strips give a reliable order of magnitude, not a precise value.

Another limitation that is often underestimated is that most strips do not measure ammonia, the most dangerous parameter in the short term. They are therefore suitable for routine checks on a mature system, never for monitoring a cycling or handling a crisis.

Drop-based water test, reagent poured into a graduated tube in front of an aquarium

Drop-type water tests, the benchmark

The colorimetric drop test remains the standard among demanding aquarists. You draw a precise volume of water into a graduated tube, add an exact number of drops of reagent, shake, then compare the resulting colour with a printed colour chart. The accuracy is clearly superior to that of test strips, with much finer scales and enough sensitivity to detect small variations. It is the most reliable affordable method for monitoring ammonia and nitrite at low concentrations, with some ammonium tests going down to 0.05 mg/L.

The price to pay is time, allow two to five minutes per parameter, and absolute rigour in following the protocol. The volume of water, the number of drops, the shaking time and the waiting time must be followed to the letter, otherwise the measurement means nothing.

Electronic pH meter with its glass probe immersed in a beaker of clear water Pocket electronic pH tester, accurate to the hundredth

The electronic pH meter

The electronic probe reads pH to the nearest decimal place, where a colorimetric test settles for half a point. In an aquaponic system where nitrification consumes alkalinity continuously, this precision changes the way you manage things: you correct a drift before it becomes a problem.

The instrument has its drawbacks, however. A pH electrode ages, gets dirty and drifts out of calibration, and a probe stored dry is only fit for the bin. It should be kept in a dedicated storage solution or, failing that, in a buffer, never in distilled water, which depletes the membrane.

The probe pays for itself when you measure often, typically in aquaponics, in hydroponics or on a closely monitored pond. For a monthly check, it mainly brings maintenance constraints with no real gain, and a good drop test is more than enough.

Which parameters should you really monitor?

Measuring fifteen parameters is pointless if the five that matter are not being monitored. The hierarchy is fairly stable, whatever the type of system. First come the three forms of nitrogen, ammonia, nitrite and nitrate, which tell the complete story of the biological filtration. Ammonia and nitrite should tend towards zero in a mature system, while nitrate accumulates and serves as fertiliser for the plants.

pH comes right behind, because it determines the comfort of the fish, the activity of the bacteria and the availability of nutrients for the crops all at once. Carbonate hardness, KH, completes the picture since it explains the stability or instability of that pH. A KH that is too low causes sudden drops that nothing else explains.

Here are the measurements that deserve a place in every test kit.

  • Total ammonia, the most dangerous parameter in the short term
  • Nitrite, a sign of an incomplete or overloaded biofilter
  • Nitrate, an indicator of the balance between fish load and growing area
  • pH, the compass of the whole system
  • KH, which explains why the pH moves

The other measurements, iron, potassium, phosphates or dissolved oxygen, are justified on a case-by-case basis. Iron becomes useful when young leaves turn yellow, a subject covered in our guide to deficiencies in aquaponics, and dissolved oxygen comes into its own during periods of intense heat.

In aquaponics, which water tests to prioritise

An aquaponic system is not run like an ornamental aquarium. The water feeds fish, nitrifying bacteria and plants all at once, and each of these three links has its own requirements. Testing is therefore less about keeping the water "clean" than about checking that the balance between the three holds.

  • Ammonia and nitrite, daily during cycling and then weekly, to check that the biofilter is coping with the fish load.
  • The pH, to be held around 7, a compromise between fish comfort, bacterial activity and nutrient uptake by the plants.
  • The KH, more often than in an aquarium, because nitrification consumes alkalinity continuously. American references for aquaponics aim for at least 100 mg/L expressed as calcium carbonate, or roughly 5 to 6 German degrees.
  • Nitrate, not to bring it down, but to judge the balance between fish and growing area.
  • Iron, as soon as the young leaves turn pale, because it is often the first element to run short in an aquaponic system.

The pack of five drop tests covers the parameters in this list apart from iron. When an iron deficiency is confirmed, the supplement is generally given as chelated iron, following the stated doses.

Calibrating a pH probe with buffer solution sachets and a soft cloth JBL ProFlora pH calibration kit, pH 7 and pH 4 buffers

Calibration, the condition for reliability

An uncalibrated electronic instrument displays numbers, not measurements. Calibration means showing the device two known values, usually a neutral buffer at pH 7 and then an acid buffer at pH 4, so that it can reset its zero and its slope.

The procedure takes two minutes. Rinse the probe in demineralised water between each bath, blot it dry without rubbing the glass membrane, then confirm each point. Recommendations vary: some sources advise calibrating before every series of measurements, others a monthly check. Keep to the practical principle: recalibrate whenever a reading looks odd. Always keep fresh buffers, because a solution that has been open for months drifts as well. A calibration carried out with an out-of-date buffer is worse than no calibration at all, since it builds in a constant error that nothing flags.

EC and TDS conductivity meter measuring the water in a grow bed of soilless lettuces

The conductivity meter and TDS

A conductivity meter measures the water's ability to conduct an electric current, which reflects the total amount of dissolved salts. The value is expressed in millisiemens per centimetre, and the TDS function is simply a conversion of that same reading into milligrams per litre, using a factor that varies from brand to brand. This tool is essential in hydroponics, where it directly governs the concentration of the nutrient solution. In aquaponics it does a different job: it gives an overall picture of the water's mineralisation and flags a slow build-up, particularly when evaporation concentrates the salts in summer. Its limitation needs to be understood. Conductivity never tells you which ions are present. A high reading may come from an excess of nitrates, sodium or calcium, three situations that call for opposite responses. It complements specific tests; it does not replace them.

Taking a water sample at mid-depth in a planted aquarium

Take your sample correctly

A measurement is only as good as the sample. Take the sample at mid-depth, away from the surface where gas exchange alters the pH, and away from the bottom where sediment skews everything. Also avoid the pump outlet and the area around the air stone.

Get into the habit of always measuring at the same spot and at the same time of day. The pH of a planted pond varies naturally over the course of the day, because photosynthesis consumes carbon dioxide. Comparing a morning reading with an evening reading is like comparing two different waters.

Analyse the sample straight away. Water left standing in a glass for an hour loses carbon dioxide and its pH rises artificially, while some of the ammonia may escape as gas. The test should be done immediately after sampling, never the next day.

Reading a colour without getting it wrong

Colorimetric reading is the weak link in the whole chain, because it depends on the eye, the light and the background. Yet three precautions are enough to make almost every measurement reliable.

The first concerns light. Always read in daylight, near a window but out of direct sunlight. Warm household lighting pulls the shades towards yellow and a cold kitchen strip light pulls them towards blue, which is enough to make you read a pale yellow where the solution is clearly green. Many false ammonia diagnoses come from this.

The second concerns the background. Place the tube on the white area provided by the manufacturer or, failing that, on a sheet of white paper, and look at the column of liquid from above rather than from the side. The optical path is longer from the top, so the shade is easier to read at low values.

The third concerns timing. Each reagent has a development time, often one to five minutes, and a reading taken too early consistently underestimates the value. Conversely, a reading taken too late lets the colour keep changing. Use a timer rather than your own estimate, and note every result in a notebook. It is the series of measurements that tells you something, far more than the single value of the day.

Water test reagent bottles stored upright, away from light

Storing your reagents properly

Colorimetric reagents are living chemicals, in the sense that they change over time. Light and heat degrade them, which explains the amber glass bottles and the advice to store them somewhere cool. Keep the case in a closed cupboard at a stable room temperature, never on a windowsill or on the heated cabinet under the aquarium. Close each bottle immediately after use and never swap two caps: a trace of cross-contaminated reagent is enough to ruin an entire bottle.

Finally, observe the expiry date printed on each bottle and write the date of opening on the label. A reagent that no longer changes colour at all on water of known quality should be replaced without hesitation.

Reagent refill bottles lined up with an empty bottle and a test tube

The real cost per measurement

The displayed price of a kit tells you almost nothing. What matters is the cost per measurement, that is, the price of the bottle divided by the number of tests it provides, usually stated in the instructions. The comparison reshuffles the cards. A test strip costs little per unit but measures several parameters at once, while a drop test costs more per parameter but lasts for years and can be refilled. An electronic probe represents a significant initial investment, followed by almost free measurements, provided you regularly buy calibration solutions and replace the electrode after roughly one to two years, depending on the manufacturer. The real way to save lies elsewhere. Buying reagent refills rather than complete kits markedly reduces the annual outlay, since the tubes, syringes and colour charts do not wear out.

How often should you test your water?

There is no universal schedule: the right frequency depends on the age of the system and on what has just happened. A new system calls for daily vigilance, while a system that has been running for two years needs only a routine monthly check.

During cycling, measure ammonia and nitrite every day or every other day. It is the only way to spot the moment when both values fall back to zero while nitrates climb, the signal that clears you to introduce the first fish. This phase generally lasts from three to eight weeks, and longer in fresh water.

After that, a sensible routine looks like this.

  • Weekly for the first two months after stocking
  • Monthly on a stable, well-established system
  • Immediately after adding fish or changing the feed
  • After cleaning a filter, a pump failure or a heatwave
  • As soon as the fish show any abnormal behaviour

Add a systematic check at each change of season. The arrival of cold weather slows the biofilter considerably, and summer concentrates salts through evaporation. These two periods account for most of the unpleasant surprises on an outdoor pond.

Test tube and reagent bottle resting on a stone at the edge of a pond in autumn KH water test, carbonate hardness, drop-based

Testing the water of an outdoor pond

A garden pond calls for a few adaptations. The volume is large, so the parameters shift more slowly, but the water is exposed to rain, fallen leaves and temperature swings, which cause unpredictable sudden changes.

Rain deserves particular attention. With very little mineral content, it dilutes the KH with every major downpour and weakens pH stability. Checking the KH after several days of rain prevents many sudden drops, a phenomenon covered in our article on pH regulation.

Finally, remember to measure at the right times. In a pond rich in plants, dissolved oxygen is at its lowest around dawn, while the pH generally peaks at the end of the day, once photosynthesis has used up the carbon dioxide. A reading taken at midday gives a flattering picture that hides the real overnight low.

Starter case with the essential tests, a pipette and a logbook

Putting together your starter case

There is no need to buy the full set of equipment on day one. An effective kit comes down to five drop tests, ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, pH and KH, to which you add a multi-parameter test strip for quick checks between full analyses. Complete it with a notebook, paper or digital, in which you record the date, the time, the reading and the day's event. This simple habit turns isolated figures into a curve, and a curve immediately tells you what a single reading never will.

Electronic instruments come later, when the need genuinely arises. A beginner well equipped with drop tests diagnoses better than a beginner equipped with a probe that has never been calibrated. Our water testing range covers both approaches.

Clean test tube next to a poorly rinsed tube covered in reagent residue

Common measurement errors

The first mistake, and by far the most common, is a badly rinsed tube. A trace of the previous reagent is enough to completely skew the next reading. Rinse three times with clean water, then once more with the water to be tested, and leave to air-dry.

The second is the approximate drop. A bottle held at an angle delivers drops of varying volume, so it must be held strictly vertical and the drop allowed to fall without squeezing too hard. On a test that calls for five drops, one drop too many means a twenty per cent error.

Then come three classics: not shaking the bottle enough before use, reading the result under artificial lighting, and testing straight after a water change. In that last case the measurement does not describe the system but the water you have just added. Wait twenty-four hours to get a representative picture.

Adapting your water tests to the water in your region

The equipment is the same everywhere, but the starting water is not, and that is what changes the way you test the most. In the north and east of France or in the Paris Basin, mains water is most often hard, with a high KH and a pH that is usually above 7.5. The pH hardly moves there, monitoring KH becomes almost secondary, and attention turns instead to the availability of iron for the plants.

In granite regions, such as Brittany or the Massif Central, the water is on the contrary soft and poorly buffered. KH then becomes the most important parameter to track, because nitrification consumes alkalinity continuously and can send the pH plunging within a few days. A KH test is just as useful there as a nitrite test.

Two units also coexist, which creates misunderstandings. European manufacturers often express hardness in German degrees, while others use ppm of calcium carbonate, with one German degree equal to roughly 17.8 ppm. Finally, some tests display ammoniacal nitrogen and others ammonium, two readings that differ by a factor of about 1.29 and cannot be compared directly. Always check the unit used before comparing your results with those from a foreign forum.

Conclusion: the best method is the one you actually use

The choice between test strips, drop tests and a probe cannot be settled in absolute terms. Strips are handy for a weekly glance, the drop test remains the serious diagnostic tool and the only one that measures ammonia properly, and the electronic probe comes into its own when you are fine-tuning a system and measuring often. Many aquaponic growers end up combining all three.

What matters more than the equipment is consistency. Five measurements tracked over time, with a constant method and a logbook, are worth more than a top-of-the-range instrument taken out three times a year. Today's reading only makes sense when compared with last week's.

So start simply, with the five essential parameters and a routine you will genuinely stick to. You will see problems coming several days before they become visible, and that is exactly what you ask of a water test.

Sources

Purdue University and Illinois-Indiana Sea Grant, Water Quality: Water Sources Used in Aquaculture (AS-486), Reference ranges for un-ionised ammonia, nitrites, iron, pH and total alkalinity

Southern Regional Aquaculture Center, Recirculating Aquaculture Tank Production Systems: Aquaponics, Integrating Fish and Plant Culture (SRAC 454), A compromise pH close to 7, with a dissolved oxygen target of 6 to 7 mg/L in aquaponics

FAO, Small-scale aquaponic food production (Somerville et al., 2014), chapter on biofilter cycling, Cycling time, from three to five weeks and up to two months in fresh water

JBL, ProAquaTest Easy 7in1, product sheet, Parameters measured by a multi-parameter test strip, excluding ammonium

Hanna Instruments, How to store your pH electrodes, Storing the electrode in a dedicated solution, never in distilled water

Hanna Instruments, What is the relationship between TDS and EC?, Conversion factor from conductivity to TDS, ranging from 0.5 to 0.7

Southern Regional Aquaculture Center, Carbon Dioxide in Fish Ponds (SRAC 468), Daily cycle of dissolved oxygen and carbon dioxide in a pond

MDPI Water, Characterizing Nutrient Composition and Concentration in Tomato-, Basil-, and Lettuce-Based Aquaponic and Hydroponic Systems, Nitrate nitrogen levels measured in aquaponics compared with hydroponics

Frequently asked questions

What matters is not the total ammonia shown by your test, but its un-ionised fraction, the only one that is truly toxic, whose proportion increases with pH and temperature. The reference values published by aquaculture extension services are deliberately low.

  • Un-ionised ammonia, from 0 to 0.05 mg/L
  • Nitrites, from 0 to 0.5 mg/L
  • Dissolved oxygen close to saturation

In other words, as soon as a drop test turns clearly positive for ammonia in a tank whose pH exceeds 7.5, consider that you are already in the risk zone and act without waiting for the next day's reading.

Yes, especially in summer and in a heavily stocked system. Aquaponic guidelines recommend keeping dissolved oxygen at around 6 to 7 mg/L, or about 80 per cent of saturation, a value that neither a test strip nor a standard colorimetric test can give you. A dedicated test or an oxygen probe becomes useful as soon as the fish density increases.

Because nitrification is an acidifying reaction. The bacteria that convert ammonia into nitrates use up the water's alkalinity, and once that reserve runs out the pH drops sharply. That is why KH deserves to be measured at least as often as the pH itself.

In aquaponics, the pH chosen as a compromise between fish comfort, biofilter activity and nutrient availability sits at around 7.0, although the biofilter remains effective over a wider range. Very soft source water therefore calls for regular additions of buffer, whereas hard water will absorb this acidification for months without difficulty.

Yes, the reagents are the same. Just check that the nitrate scale goes high enough, because a mature aquaponic system reaches levels that an ornamental aquarium never sees.

In an aquarium, this reading would call for a partial water change. In aquaponics, it is commonplace and rather reassuring, since nitrate is the main source of nitrogen for the crops. Analyses published on commercial aquaponic systems commonly report nitrate-nitrogen levels in the region of a hundred milligrams per litre, well below those of a standard hydroponic solution. Watch the vigour of your plants instead, as they are the ones using up this stock.

This is probably the most worthwhile test of all, because it explains in advance how your system will behave. Three values are worth noting down once and for all.

  • Total alkalinity, for which the reference ranges in fish farming run from about 50 to 400 mg/L of calcium carbonate
  • The pH, which should sit in a range of roughly 6.5 to 9.0 depending on the species
  • Total iron, to be kept below 0.15 mg/L in cold water and below 0.5 mg/L in warm water

Borehole or well water calls for extra vigilance, as it often arrives low in oxygen and loaded with dissolved iron, which precipitates on contact with the air.

Read next

Green pond water: 5 solutions

Green pond water: 5 solutions

In the middle of summer, the water in your pond turns an opaque green and you can no longer see your fish. Good news : five natural solutions, well combined, are enough to restore

Read the article
Salmonponics: aquaponics in cold water

Salmonponics: aquaponics in cold water

Aquaponics is often associated with pond fish like goldfish and koi. However, there is a variant perfectly suited for our temperate regions, cool climates, and winters : salmoponics. Trout, char, brook trout, these iconic

Read the article
UV steriliser for ponds

UV steriliser for ponds

A pond UV steriliser eliminates the single-celled algae responsible for green water, provided it is correctly sized and fitted at the right point in the circuit. This guide covers the power to choose, the

Read the article
Protecting your aquaponic system in winter

Protecting your aquaponic system in winter

Winter is a critical period for an aquaponic system: the pond may freeze, bacterial activity collapses and the fish's metabolism slows right down. With the right habits and a minimum of equipment, you can

Read the article
Transporting your fish without stress

Transporting your fish without stress

The journey between the seller and your pond rarely lasts more than a few hours, but it is often the most dangerous moment in an ornamental fish's life. A few simple steps are enough

Read the article
Protecting your pond from predators

Protecting your pond from predators

Heron, cat, kingfisher, or cormorant, most pond predators are protected by law and can only be deterred using passive devices. This guide brings together the figures that work, the devices that have proven effective,

Read the article

Discover our aquaponics greenhouses and kits:

View all
Produits du rayon Kits d'aquaponie chez Univers Aquaponie

Aquaponics kits

Aquaponics kits ready to install in the garden, on a patio or in a greenhouse, with fish tank, grow beds and pump.

Discover
Produits du rayon Univers Plantes chez Univers Aquaponie

Plants

Seeds, grow media, fertilisers and aquatic plants for successful growing in aquaponics, hydroponics and the vegetable garden.

Discover
Produits du rayon Univers Équipements chez Univers Aquaponie

Equipment Universe

The equipment that keeps a system running: soilless growing, water circulation and aeration, filtration, temperature, plumbing and lighting.

Discover
Produits du rayon Serres d'aquaponie chez Univers Aquaponie

Aquaponics greenhouses

Greenhouses designed for aquaponics, supplied with their fish tank and grow towers.

Discover
Produits du rayon Univers Poissons chez Univers Aquaponie

Fish

Feed, monitor the water and care for your pond, aquarium or aquaponic fish.

Discover
Produits du rayon Univers Formation chez Univers Aquaponie

Learning

Books and practical courses on aquaponics, hydroponics and food self-sufficiency.

Discover